Tuberville In the News: Newsweek: Supreme Court Student Debt Cancellation Decision Sparks Dueling Proposals

Republican and Democratic senators on Wednesday issued dueling proposals aimed to deal with the inordinate costs and processes associated with higher education, though both plans are vastly different in their approaches.

The Supreme Court is expected to make a decision this week on whether the Biden administration’s student loan forgiveness plan, which would erase federal student loan debt for approximately 20 million and lower balances for another 20 million, is constitutional. The court will look at two challenges: one involving six Republican-led states, and a lawsuit filed by two students.

President Joe Biden recently vetoed the Congressional Review Act (CRA) resolution following debates about the debt ceiling. The resolution included support from Republican and some Democratic senators and intended to overturn Biden’s student debt cancelation plan and the loan repayment pause which Republicans estimated would cost taxpayers nearly $600 billion.

GOP members estimated that the repayment pause, which is set to expire 60 days after the June 30 Supreme Court deadline, cost taxpayers $5 billion a month in uncollected fees for a total estimated balance of $195 billion. The initial pause was enacted by former President Donald Trump at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic.

“The president’s student loan schemes do not ‘forgive’ debt, they just shift the burden from those who chose to take out loans onto those who never went to college or already fulfilled their commitment to pay off their loans,” said Republican Senator Bill Cassidy following the successful 52-46 vote.

“Our bipartisan resolution prevents average Americans, the 87 percent of whom currently have no student loans, from being forced to foot the bill of these unfair and irresponsible policies.”

Cassidy, along with Senators John Cornyn, Chuck GrassleyTommy Tuberville and Tim Scott, introduced a five-bill package Wednesday called the Lowering Education Costs and Debt Act.

The legislation intends to “create downward pressure on the cost of colleges and universities” while offering prospective college students and their parents or guardians better information to choose the right school and program to achieve the best return on investment for them—in essence, preventing students from unintentionally taking out more loans than they can pay off in the long run.

These are the five bills:

  • College Transparency Act (CTA): This reforms the college data reporting system for students and families to provide better information while assisting businesses and other employers in finding potential employees best suited for a particular field. It was previously introduced by Cassidy and other Republicans and Democrats in April.
  • Understanding the True Cost of College Act: It requires higher education institutions to use a uniform financial aid letter with clear indications of the types (scholarships, loans, work-study, etc.) of aid, breaking them down for easy understanding and comparison.
  • Informed Student Borrowing Act: Prior to enrollment, students will have more information about their academic needs and financial responsibilities—including the duration of their loan, their expected monthly payment, and how much money they will likely make in their desired career fields.
  • Streamlining Accountability and Value in Education (SAVE) for Students Act: It reduces the number of repayment options from nine to two options: the 10-year standard repayment plan, plus REPAYE+ and an income-driven repayment plan that provides earlier forgiveness for low-income, low-balance undergraduate borrowers.
  • It also prohibits new federal student loans from paying for undergraduate programs in which half of the former students are unable to earn a salary higher than the median high school graduate and prohibits loans from paying for graduate programs in which half of the former students are unable to earn more than a median bachelor’s degree recipient.
  • Graduate Opportunity and Affordable Loans (GOAL) Act: If enacted, it would end inflationary Graduate PLUS loans and limit graduate school borrowing, and allow institutions to set lower loan limits by program to protect students from overborrowing.

Ty Bofferding, spokesperson for the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee, told Newsweek that PSLF and the other 25-ish other loan forgiveness programs remain and will be untouched by this bill package. Interest on loan repayments is not addressed in this legislation.

Cassidy said Wednesday during a press conference that the Biden administration’s plan is “not a fix but merely a Band-Aid,” saying this new GOP plan “addresses the root causes.”

“Young people are paying a lot more for higher education and getting a lot less, and that’s wrong…This is one step to restoring sanity to our education system,” Tuberville said. “It’s out of control. We’ve got our work cut out on all levels.”